Nov 19, 2026


Not cashing a check does not always keep income off this year's return. This article explains the constructive receipt rule, how it applies to year-end payments and farm sales, and how a properly structured deferred payment contract fits in.
When Is Income Really Received?
Most taxpayers, including most farmers, ranchers, and small business owners, report income on the cash method. Income is reported in the year it is received, and expenses are deducted in the year they are paid. It is a simple system, and for most transactions it works exactly as expected.
At year-end, however, a common question comes up: if a payment is available in December but is not picked up, deposited, or cashed until January, which year does it belong to? Many people assume the answer is simply the year the money reaches the bank.
Understanding the Rule
Under the Treasury Regulations, income does not have to be in your hands to be taxable. Income is considered constructively received in the year it is credited to your account, set apart for you, or otherwise made available so that you could draw on it at any time. In simple terms, if the money is yours for the taking, the IRS generally treats it as received, whether or not you choose to ask for it. The rule exists to prevent taxpayers from moving income from one year to another simply by choosing not to collect it.
The Important Exception
The regulations also provide that income is not constructively received when your control over it is subject to substantial limitations or restrictions.
In practice, this usually comes down to two questions. First, could you have received the payment this year if you had asked for it? Second, if you could not, was the restriction a genuine one, agreed to with the payer, or one you created yourself? A limitation you impose on your own income, such as asking a buyer to hold a check, generally does not qualify.
Common Examples
Constructive receipt tends to come up in a handful of familiar situations.
A check received in December but deposited in January. A check is generally income when you receive it, not when you deposit it. Leaving it in a desk drawer until after the new year does not change the year it belongs to.
A payment you asked the buyer to hold. If a sale barn, elevator, or customer is ready to pay in December and you ask them to hold the check until January, that payment is generally income in December. The money was available; you simply chose not to take it.
Wages or a bonus available at year-end. If a paycheck or bonus is ready for you on December 31 and you pick it up on January 2, it is generally income in the year it was made available.
By contrast, a check that is mailed on December 31 and arrives in January is generally income in January. You did not have access to it until it arrived, and that is a real limitation rather than a choice.
Deferred Payment Contracts for Farmers and Ranchers
For Montana producers, the most important application of this rule is the deferred payment contract. Selling grain or livestock in one year and being paid in the next can be a legitimate and effective way to manage taxable income, but only when the arrangement is set up correctly.
The IRS has long recognized that a farmer who enters a bona fide, arm's-length contract with a buyer, under which payment is not due until a fixed date in the following year, does not have constructive receipt in the year of delivery. The key is that the farmer never had the right to be paid earlier.
To hold up, a deferred payment contract should generally:
Be in place, in writing, before the grain or livestock is delivered
Set a specific payment date in the following year
Not allow you to receive any part of the proceeds before that date
Not be transferable or assignable
The order of events matters. A contract signed after the sale, or an informal request to split a check between December and January, generally does not qualify. If you receive any part of the deferred proceeds early, the entire amount may become taxable in the year of sale.
A Final Thought
Constructive receipt is less about when money reaches your bank account and more about when you had the right to it. Understanding that distinction can help prevent an unexpected adjustment and allow year-end planning to work as intended.
If you are considering deferring a sale or payment into next year, we encourage you to visit with us before the transaction, while there is still time to structure it correctly.
Swanson Agency. Montana Roots. Future Focused.
You might also be interested in these articles:





